My $50 logo designs on Fiverr are getting crushed by $5 logos. And honestly? Some of the $5 logos are decent.

💼 Freelance & Serviceby fiverr_bottom · 3w ago

▸ What I did

Graphic designer doing logo work on Fiverr for a year. I charge $50 for a custom logo: research the client's industry, sketch concepts, deliver 3 options with revisions. Each logo takes me 4-6 hours.

▸ What I expected

$50 is already the budget end of logo design. Figured there'd be plenty of clients who want quality without agency prices. Aimed for 15-20 logos/month.

▸ What actually happened

I get maybe 3-4 orders per month. The Fiverr search results are dominated by sellers offering logos for $5-15 with "unlimited revisions" and 24-hour delivery. Some use AI generation. And some of the $5 logos look genuinely decent. I'm competing against "good enough" and "good enough" is winning.

▸ What I've tried so far

Optimized my Fiverr gig with better thumbnails and description. Added a video introduction. Got "Fiverr's Choice" badge temporarily. Tried raising to $75 — even fewer orders. Tried adding brand identity packages ($200) — got 1 sale in 2 months.

Progress Updates (1)

Taking advice from this community and trying a vertical niche. Instead of "logo design for anyone," I'm repositioning as "brand identity for restaurants." Why restaurants: they need more than just a logo (menu design, signage, social media templates), they're local (can meet in person), and they're underserved by $5 Fiverr sellers who can't do industry-specific work. Made a new Fiverr gig: "Complete Restaurant Brand Package — Logo + Menu Design + Social Templates for $250." Also joined 2 restaurant owner Facebook groups. First week: 1 inquiry from Fiverr, 2 DMs from Facebook. Small signal but it's more interest than my generic logo gig got in a month.

0 / 3000

2 Replies

ux_first_kai · 1w ago✓ the fix

Fiverr's marketplace is designed for commodity services. A logo is a commodity on Fiverr. A "restaurant brand identity" is NOT a commodity because it requires industry knowledge, not just design skill. Your niche pivot is the right move. Go further: don't just niche on Fiverr, build a simple portfolio site with ONLY restaurant branding work. Then when a restaurant owner Googles "restaurant logo designer" they find a specialist, not a generalist on a marketplace. Specialists get to name their price.

ecom_realist · 1w ago

The $250 restaurant package is smart because you're bundling things that the client would otherwise need to buy separately from 3-4 different sellers. A logo from one person, menu design from another, social templates from a third. You're offering convenience + consistency + industry expertise in one package. That's a value proposition that $5 logo sellers literally cannot compete with.

Status

⏳ figuring

Stats

Me too0

Replies2

Following0